Have a tendency to when schedules are given, he is considering with a day of day you to definitely do maybe not matches with this time whilst inside the genuine records. One example occurs in Harry Potter and Prisoner from Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney makes reference to sixteen October because Saturday, regardless if sixteen Oct 1993 is a saturday.
There are also contradictions in the books of this type. Such as for instance, when you look at the Harry Potter as well as the Goblet away from Flame, both step one September and you will 2 Sep are given because Mondays and, from inside the Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demo is set on 20 April, but careful parsing of one’s text message indicates that this may has actually taken place no later than March.
And, in the Harry Potter and the Cup out-of Fire they state that the Winners have been chose into the Saturday 31 October, however, 30 Oct is actually a tuesday during the 1994.
Into the a bankruptcy proceeding regarding Quidditch From Years, it is said that basic Quidditch Industry Cup was held in the 1473. If your title is actually held all of the four years, that it disputes into declaration within the Goblet out-of Flames your 1994 Community Glass try new 422nd. If Quidditch From the Decades is useful, brand new 422nd Quidditch Globe Glass carry out indeed fall in the year 3161, however, if Cup off Flame is great, the initial World Mug is held within the 306.
Historical trouble [ ]
As the show, with regards to the schedule based on this new Chamber out-of Treasures resource, is determined regarding 1990s, the latest show usually appears as if it’s invest the fresh new late 1990s in order to middle-2000s, around concurrent into the book of the books. Into the Harry Potter and the 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a masculine pronoun to mention on “predecessor” of Primary Minister of Uk. Depending on the above timeline, this should take place in the summer months regarding 1996, if Finest Minister is actually John Significant, whoever immediate ancestor are a female (‘s first interviewing Fudge, the ebook says the election, however, Big was not initial picked and just got more than shortly after Thatcher resigned.
It’s possible, although not unrealistic, that Fudge was making reference to a very faraway predecessor, once the Thatcher got office just before Fudge click over here now supposedly turned Minister to own Secret. (Even in the event one can consider a situation in which Fudge are delegated because of the Minister for Wonders to satisfy for the Prime Minister as he, Fudge, was in an inferior place of work.) Likewise, the identification and reputation for the top Minister illustrated appears to more directly suits compared to Tony Blair than regarding John Biggest. A blog post from the Each and every day Send cards you to Rowling is intimate towards next-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brown (have a tendency to regarded as a competition to Blair’s frontrunners of Work Class, who succeeded your and turned into Perfect Minister), which she might have been wanting to let you know Blair’s terrible side. If the books were set in sync which have guide day regarding Philosopher’s Stone, after that this event create occur in 2002 (once Blair turned into Primary Minister).
However, it absolutely was later reported that twenty-two November are a tuesday, which it was in 1994
A similar disease concerns Nicolas Flamel, who was said as being 665 during the time of the fresh first publication, but Nicolas Flamel is actually a genuine historic figure and would not have reached one age up to 1996, around the time the first book are authored. The fresh rebuttal for it is the fact that the go out the brand new “real” Nicolas Flamel was born does not keep in touch with the latest Nicolas Flamel from Harry Potter.
A different sort of problem is obtainable off Rubeus Hagrid’s period since the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is required in the series one to Hagrid got you to position within a few years out of their expulsion of college from inside the 1942. However in one to scene out-of Harry Potter as well as the Goblet from Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper appear to overlap having Molly’s ages in school, it appears unrealistic you to definitely she remembers a past gamekeeper. However, you are able you to Hagrid did not getting a beneficial gamekeeper quickly once are expelled, but instead been since the Ogg’s secretary. This can be probable since when Harry believes which he commonly feel expelled having flying for the broomstick in the place of consent in the first 12 months, he wonders in the event that however be allowed to stick to because Hagrid’s assistant.